Essay - Critique of a Qualitative Research Critique of Qualitative Research Phenomenon...

Critique of a Qualitative Research

CRITIQUE OF QUALITATIVE RESEARCH

***** ***** Interest & Purpose

The purpose of the study is to explore and describe ***** experiences relatives have while taking care of their critically ill patients that are confined in the intensive c***** unit (ICU). Th***** study aims to scrutinize this phenomenon using a qu*****litative method. *****e ***** of this study was clearly stated. It defined the subject to be studied and the method. The term "relative" ***** further defined to avoid confusion and to clearly define the subjects for observation. Relatives stood for anyone close ***** looking after the patient in ***** ICU. The objective of the study was limited to an ICU ***** a D*****nish university hospital. The study also aimed ***** ***** ***** points of view of these relatives including their perception of the roles of an ***** nurse.

The ***** of interest in this case is to observe and ***** the ***** of relatives whose loved ones are confined in the ICU. This is of significance *****cause relatives go through several psychological stresses when their ***** ones are suddenly taken ill. Having a loved one in an ***** implies that there ***** a chance ***** this patient may not survive. Relatives find themselves in a situation where they are uncerta***** about the future. They ***** even be in a state of shock. Relatives, like their admitted ***** ones, need adequate attention and support from health care providers. ICU *****s must then be able to provide holistic ***** not only to the patient but the *****' relatives as well. A deeper understand*****g of ***** ********** experiences and their consequent needs may guide the ICU nurse in catering ***** ********** needs better.

The authors rationalized why a qualitative method ***** ***** over a quantitative approach. ***** used other studies to justify their preference for ***** approach. In ***** *****, in-depth interviews are conducted. A qualitative approach enables researchers ***** explore relatives' experiences beyond a single question. On the o*****r h*****, the use of *****n*****ires in the ***** ***** ***** fail to touch on important concerns of these relatives. A quantitative approach fails to allow relatives to expound or elaborate on ***** percepti***** of the *****. Because of *****se limitations, a qualitative method was preferred.

Descriptive Vividness

The ***** were able ***** describe the aspects of the study clearly. However, *****re were some aspects of the study that were described with ambiguity. In *****s of the ***** site, the authors only described it as ***** ICU in a Danish ***** hospital; it failed to state which hospital was the focus. The credibility of ***** study would ***** been more developed if the identity of the ***** was concretized. The sett*****g of ***** interview was also described in detail; the *****s ***** conducted in a quiet room at the hospital or ***** the rel*****ive's home. ***** authors ***** described the participants or subjects vividly. Seven relatives were interviewed, four spouses and three parents. Their ages ranged ***** 39 to 72