Should Girls Play Baseball … Research Proposal
Pages: 6 (1947 words) | Style: MLA | Sources: 10
Girls Playing Baseball
The research undertaken in this particular paper attends to the aspect whether girls should be allowed to play baseball as opposed to softball. In fact, this issue has been there for quite a while. The main issue is that women ought to be given the same opportunities as men. My position in this particular issue stands in support of women. In my own opinion, I believe women ought to be given rights, liberties and opportunities in a similar way as men are given. However, it is imperative for them to have a complete understanding of the consequences such actions entail, and ought to be ready and prepared to follow through with such actions. There is a great deal of literature that discusses the aspect of girls and women in general being included in the game of baseball. In several instances, right from the young age, girls are discouraged from taking part in baseball activities and are instead encouraged to participate in softball. This view is not balanced, as every individual ought to be handed the freedom to participate in whichever sport they love and seek to pursue irrespective of their gender or sexual category. Girls should be allowed to play in Little League Teams alongside boys (Coakely, 50).
Discrimination in baseball started in the 19th Century. Women were largely subjected to discrimination in the sport of baseball because it was perceived to be improper conduct and behavior for a young woman. However, it can also be argued that due to societal predispositions, most women at the time did not fervently aspire to play baseball. Nonetheless, a team The Bloomer Girls, which was an all-women's team was created in the 1890s period (Ball State University, n.d). This team made claims that they had defeated all the men's baseball teams that they had played against on several occasions. This all-women's team was quite popular and loved by the crowds and fans. However, they faced much scrutiny and discrimination from the press. Several newspapers at the time reasoned that the only cause why The Bloomer Girls were skilled and capable in baseball was because the team administrators made men dress up like women and then play for the all-women's team (Ball State University, n.d). This can be perceived to be discriminatory as it was difficult for majority of the people to believe that women could, in fact be able to defeat men in the game of baseball. More so, a number of churches were not in support of the notion of women playing baseball. Instead, they were constantly in favor of the idea of women not being on the field playing but rather on the stands offering support and cheering their brothers and husbands playing (Ball State University, n.d).
There have been several arguments and cases made against girls being included in the Little League and having mixed teams. One of the arguments made is that girls being included in Little League Teams and playing with boys would detract them from the game. This is in the sense that playing with girls might cause the boys to be more protective and thereby less aggressively, which is not in the best interests of the development and competitiveness of the game. The girls and boys would be distracted from the game if they played together in several instances. For instance, a boy would not have an effective pitch to a girl he has a liking to. There would be several instances where the girls or the boys would try to impress each other and therefore take their eyes away from the game. As such, it is argued that including the girls in the games would dilute the zeal and fierce competition and take away the intensity that is usually expected and experienced during the game (Thornton, 495). More so, it is perceived that girls might be prone to injuries and would need first aid constantly, breaking the continuity. Arguments are also made that the girls would rather have a preference to play with other girls. A point was also lodged that having mixed teams which include both boys and girls would cause the boys to hold back largely because they consider girls to be less able to protect themselves during the game. For instance, the boys would pitch a less intensive game due to the girls in the fear that they might be injured (Thornton, 495). Another negative that is considered is that women might end up getting hurt in the process or the men could hurt them intentionally. For instance, if, and when the males find out that the women have greater ability and talent in the game compared to them, it is feared that they might get more aggressive towards the girls and hurt them on purpose. On the other hand, it is considered that men might feel that they are not able to play to the best of their abilities simply because they are playing against a woman. All of these reasons are 'pitched' against including girls in playing baseball as opposed to softball.
The solution to this aspect is to follow a number of steps. This follows the reasons given for and against the participation of girls being allowed to participate with the boys in the baseball league in the legal case Fortin v. Darlingto0n Little League, Inc. (Thornton, 496; Champion, 57). To start with, it is important to consider whether the girl has the physical ability to play with the boys in the baseball team. One of the major arguments made against girls playing baseball is that they are not physically able to match the strength that the boys have at the age. However, actually, this is not the case. Evidence indicates that girls who are the age of the Little League are physically capable and can safely play baseball with the boys and not be forced to take the softball route. This is largely owing to the fact that girls who are between the ages of 8 and 12 years are generally bigger and as strong or even stronger than boys of the equivalent age. This implies that the girls are no more prone to experience fracture or other injuries, no more unbalanced on their feet, are neurologically alike, and have the similar quantity of fat as boys of similar age (Thornton, 497).
In general, these physical attributes mentioned indicate that the girls in this age are very capable physical -- strength wise to play alongside the boys in Little League Baseball teams. The only notable physical disparity at these ages is that girls have a lower respirational or lung capacity compared to boys. However, from a medical point-of-view, this difference is not enough cause to hinder the girls' capability to play baseball. More so, evidence has been provided by radiologists indicating that the bones of girls are not in any way different from those of boys and that in a skeletal manner are no more susceptible to injury or unbalanced in comparison to boys (Thornton, 497).
According to (Ardell, 223), the case being made against girls not being included in baseball sporting activities is not justified. This follows the fact that the same teams allow and permit boys who are injured to participate in such games. However, it is important to point out that the girls are capable of having equal if not better physical strength and physical capability compared to such boys. Girls at such ages grow and mature at a faster rate compared to boys. Consequently, the girls have a tendency of being bigger in size compared to the boys. Little League include boys who are yet to reach their adolescent age and therefore have not yet had the physical attributes that eventually grow on them. Therefore, this implies that girls have the right, required reasons to be included in the teams. One other argument made against the participation in the game of baseball is a lack of protection during the actual game. However, this argument is not a strong one. The reason being, such aspects can be easily trained and imbued into them by the coaches, in the same way as at the outset, the boys too, included in the teams have no expertise in the different aspects of the game and have to be trained and taught by the coaches. This can be done for the girls too, as they have the same potential and capability as their male counterparts (Thornton, 500).
Another advanced move would be to make amendments to Title IX. This is largely because; in as much as Title IX might have increased opportunities and prospects for girls in softball, soccer, swimming, and basketball, it did not do the same for baseball (Simon, 44). This can be seen by the fact that when a girl outgrows the Little League, then she faces being caught or trapped in a long-lasting rundown and derelict (Stevens, 156). This is because in as much the girl has ambitions and aspirations; she does… [END OF PREVIEW]
Cite This Paper:
APA FormatShould Girls Play Baseball. (2015, October 25). Retrieved April 25, 2017, from http://www.essaytown.com/subjects/paper/girls-play-baseball/6014720
MLA Format"Should Girls Play Baseball." 25 October 2015. Web. 25 April 2017. <http://www.essaytown.com/subjects/paper/girls-play-baseball/6014720>.
Chicago Format"Should Girls Play Baseball." Essaytown.com. October 25, 2015. Accessed April 25, 2017.