Case Study: Antonio

Pages: 6 (2204 words)  ·  Bibliography Sources: 6  ·  Level: Master's  ·  Topic: Family and Marriage  ·  Buy for $19.77

Social Work

Antonio Case Study

Define resilience and then discuss both adaptive and maladaptive functioning in Antonio's family based on Walsh's, "three keys to family resilience"

Instinctively resilience is about being able to be flexible and also about the ability to be capable of adapting. it's about the ability to take in malfunctions and still remain on task. It is also about the ability to organize along with the capability to learn, change and (Neil Adger on Social Resilience, 2010). In the case of Antonio, his father Daniel does not show any resilience at all. He appears to have a problem dealing with change. He seems to be happiest when things go his way and no alterations are involved.

The three keys to family resilience are belief systems, organizational resources and communication processes. Belief systems comprise making sense out of crisis and challenge, maintaining a positive outlook of hope and having transcendence and spirituality. Organizational resources include suppleness and stability, connectedness to leadership and kin, social and economic resources. The communication processes includes apparent, reliable messages, emotional sharing together with humor, joy and respite along with mutual problem-solving (Walsh, 2010).

Antonio's mother displays adaptive behavior in her belief system. Adaptive behavior is a kind of behavior that is utilized to adjust to an additional type of behavior or circumstances. It is often described by a kind of performance that permits a person to change an unhelpful or troublesome performance to something more positive. These actions are most often social or personal actions (Kendall, 2008). Hilda displays an outlook of hope and has a very strong tie to her spirituality. Hilda also shows adaptive behavior in regards to her organizational resources. She has strong ties to her family and relies on them heavily for support. She believes very much in the institution of marriage and believes that she needs to do whatever she can to uphold the promises that she made before God.

In the area of communication processes, Antonio's parents display maladaptive behavior. A maladaptive behavior is an action or mannerism that is not adaptive. It is counterproductive to the people. Maladaptive actions are frequently utilized as a gauge of irregularity or mental dysfunction (Kendall, 2008). Hilda and Daniel do not appear to communicate well at all. There seems to be more arguing and fighting that anything else. Hilda does whatever she can to make Daniel happy and yet no matter what she does it is not good enough to please him. He has issue with change and conflict and does not do a good job of communicating his feelings. Instead he often lashes out with violence.

3A. Identify three defense mechanisms that Antonio uses, providing an example of each and explaining why it's either adaptive or maladaptive.

Defense mechanisms often start as healthy adaptations in order to deal with concern, sorrow, terror, irritation or harm They are used to protect ones self against danger and to evade or manage dominant, frightening feelings. Defense mechanisms help a person to preserve self-esteem and an optimistic sense of self (Mannelli, n.d.) Three defense mechanisms that Antonio uses are splitting, omnipotent control and devaluation and idealization.

Splitting is a primitive defense mechanism in where a person transfers experiences or people into all-good and all-bad groups with no room for uncertainty. It is thought to derive from a time prior to a child developing object constancy. Children are thought to see their mother as all good when they are made happy and perceive her as a bad mother when they are aggravated. They have not yet developed the ability to understand that she is the same person in each circumstance whose attendance feels good and bad at times (Mannelli, n.d.). This can be seen in the case when Antonio is so attached to his mother when she is dropping him off at daycare. He wants so bad to spend all of his time with her that he become upset and angry when she leaves him, even it is only for a few hours. This behavior is maladaptive because it does not allow for Antonio to gain any good from the socialization process at daycare because he spends the majority of his time angry at this mother for leaving him.

Omnipotent control is a childish state of showiness, where the fantasy is that one is in control of all they come in contact with. This is a usual stage of expansion for children but as they grow up, they shift this defense into a stage where the main caregiver is thought to be all-powerful, developing into the real but unpleasant fact that no one's authority is unlimited. It is hypothesized by psychologists, that the sentiment that one's power is not boundless and that it is essential developmentally, where the child can liberally enjoy the fantasies of one's own all-powerfulness and next, that of the caretakers on whom one relies (Mannelli, n.d.). Antonio displays this defensive mechanism when he acts out his fantasies with his super hero toys. He sees his dad as being evil and his mother as the hero. This behavior is adaptive in that it allows Antonio the occasion to work through the feelings that he has about his father and his abusive behavior.

Idealization and devaluation are thought to originate from a child's want to believe that the caretakers, mommy or daddy, can guard them from dangers. Children are scared to confront the realism of unfriendliness, sickness, death, and other fears for the first time, and idealization of the caretakers guards them against devastating fear and permits them to feel sheltered, cushioned from too harsh a blow from reality (Mannelli, n.d.). Antonio is seen as idealizing his mother. He always wants to spend all of his time with her and not very often with anyone else. He feels that his mother can protect him from his father and thus she is his hero. This behavior is maladaptive in that it does not allow Antonio to develop any social relationships with other people including his teachers and his peers.

Part B

2B. What is Antonio's current level of ego mastery? Incorporate a discussion of his ego strengths and weaknesses to support the answer

The ego tries to autonomously master its surroundings and communications. In mastering the ego a sense of one's effectance has to be cared for (Bracey, 2010). A fit ego in a child is believed to drive that child to the next level of development, with each level presenting new chances. The ego plays a major role in the growth as it struggles for fitness and mastery of the surroundings. Societal institutions and caretakers offer positive support for the growth of personal efficiency (Greene, 1999). In this case Antonio has not yet mastered his ego. This can be seen in the fact that he has trouble forming social relationships with anyone other than his mother. People's ego strengths comprise the relative intactness of reality testing, the relative intactness of thought procedures, the relative intactness of interpersonal associations and the relative intactness of the variation of reality. The ego weaknesses include the mixture of poor desire control and poor frustration acceptance, the liking to use primitive ego defenses, the syndrome of identity dispersal and sentimental unsteadiness (Goldstein, 2001).

Antonio is lacking in his ego strength to foster interpersonal relations. He only wants to socialize with his mother. He never formed any strong relationships with the caretakers at daycare and only formed a half hearted relationship with one of his peers. Antonio also demonstrated weak ego displays in the fact that he often demonstrated signs of frustration and used primitive ego defenses in order to help him cope with the problems that were going on at home. He often has bouts of crying and acting out that showed his lack of impulse control.

3B. Does Antonio have a good fit with his environment? Include 4 ecological concepts in the answer, and how would a Deep Ecology or Eco-Feminist perspective enrich the assessment of Antonio? Be specific.

Human ecology is the systematic appliance of ecological concepts, main beliefs, and theory and research methods to the study of human populations and communities. Human ecology looks at the manner in which human population resource associations affect the variation of human populations to dissimilar ecosystems. It also looks at the role that the resource necessities desired to maintain a population play in shaping local differences in continuation, labor allotment, technology, reproductive actions, residential allocation, household composition and arrangement, community social and political association, inter-population relations and other social behaviors (Abruzzi, 1982). In this case Antonio does not have a good fit with his environment. His household composition is not ideal since his father is abusive which has lead to his mom and dad being separated. He has problems developing healthy interpersonal relationships with his teachers and peers due to the fact that he has an issue with always wanting to be with his mother. The family's social organization was not the best considering the fact that when… [END OF PREVIEW]

Leading Change Carlos Ghosn at Renault and Nissan Case Study


Ward's Cove Packing Company v. Antonio Term Paper


Calveta Dining Services: A Plan for Change Capstone Project


Addressing Wireless Networking Technology and Security a Moving Target Research Proposal


Zimbardo's Prison Study Term Paper


View 169 other related papers  >>

Cite This Case Study:

APA Format

Antonio.  (2010, December 3).  Retrieved November 17, 2019, from https://www.essaytown.com/subjects/paper/antonio-case-study/91709

MLA Format

"Antonio."  3 December 2010.  Web.  17 November 2019. <https://www.essaytown.com/subjects/paper/antonio-case-study/91709>.

Chicago Format

"Antonio."  Essaytown.com.  December 3, 2010.  Accessed November 17, 2019.
https://www.essaytown.com/subjects/paper/antonio-case-study/91709.