Homosexuals in the Military Research Paper

Pages: 5 (1820 words)  ·  Bibliography Sources: 4  ·  File: .docx  ·  Topic: Military

Buy full Download Microsoft Word File paper
for $19.77

Military

Homosexuals in the Military

The matter of gays in the military has been a hot political dispute ever since the commencement of Don't Ask, Don't Tell. Essentially, liberals want to permit gays to candidly serve in the military, while conservatives want to keep the present Don't Ask, Don't Tell, policy, or desire to ban gays from serving in the armed forces altogether (Powers, 2010). Don't Ask, Don't Tell allows for the release of an American soldier for coming out as gay, lesbian, or bisexual. But for one of the exceptions to the law, the rule bans anyone who shows a tendency or intention to partake in homosexual acts from serving in the military of the United States. The notion is that it would generate an undesirable danger to the high principles of spirits, good array and regulation, and unit consistency that are the core of armed forces ability. The act forbids any homosexual or bisexual individual from revealing their sexual orientation or from talking about any homosexual relations, including marriages or other familial characteristics, while serving in the United States military. The don't ask element of the policy designates that superiors should not commence examination of a service member's orientation in the lack of prohibited actions, though simple doubt of homosexual actions can cause an inquiry. While President Bush was accommodating of Don't Ask Don't Tell, President Barack Obama pledged to get rid of the policy and permit gays to serve candidly in the United States armed forces (Debate: Gays in the U.S. military, 2010).

Proponents of gays serving in the armed forces say that it is the correct thing to do given America's well recognized conviction in and venerable fight for equality. This disagreement is hard to contest for the reason that it is one of the most significant doctrines of American life, one that divides us from other countries and about which we smugly and justly boast. In addition this is the identical fight that was used in opposition to women and African-Americans and it turned out to be false. Neither one of those two populations disparaged the armed forces in any manner, nor neither will the gays (McGann, 2010).

Another argument is that homosexuals have already served in all wars that America has been in. Once more this principle is also factual. Homosexuals have served in all of America's wars from the Revolutionary War on and have put their lives on the line right beside other soldiers, but they did so in quiet. The majority of soldiers were oblivious of the homosexuals among them and those that did find out generally did not care as long as everybody did their job. This disagreement shows that homosexuals can and have served, and should be allowed to continue to do so (McGann, 2010).

Proponents also bring up the point that a lot of our military partners have laws permitting homosexuals to serve and have made gains from them. Many of our military partners do in fact allow gays to serve in their militaries forces and have had little trouble become accustomed provided that all personnel were appropriately instructed as to precisely what the new rules were. In those countries where the draft was obligatory the enclosure of gays and lesbians in the military became compulsory to assure that all people were uniformly dedicated to serving their nation. Israel is an ideal illustration of this particularly in light of the high view their armed force is held all through the world. This fight favors gays serving in the military in a voluntary army but particularly so where a draft is set up (McGann, 2010).

The last major argument is that don't ask, don't tell is not working as it stands now. DADT is, in fact, not functioning as well as those who support it would want everyone to think. It costs between $25,000 and $50,000 or more to teach a soldier who can then be let go if their same sex fondness is exposed. There are about 66,000 gays and lesbians presently serving in forced silence, according to the UCLA's Williams Institute. The Service members Legal Defense Network reports that since 1993 more than 13,000 gay and lesbian troops have been let go. Serious ability deficiencies such as Arabic linguists, fighter pilots and doctors have been released only for the reason that they were gay at a time when they are needed the most while fighting two wars. Hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars have been wasted by way of the expenses of gay inquiries and releases, and in then teaching their surrogates, according to the Government Accountability Office. There is also an additional fight in opposition to the DADT strategy that should be dealt with, namely that this strategy forces people to lie thus compromising their honesty. This is no little issue and ponders a great deal in opposition to keeping the DADT rule (McGann, 2010).

It's time for the army to get rid of its ban on homosexuals entirely. The current don't ask, don't tell rule is too unclear. it's simple to say that the augment in releases has resulted from deliberate announcements of sexual preference, but a better question is trickier to answer. Are the announcements being produced because of authorized inquiries or persecution? A pitch in supposed strategy infringements points to the fact that the rule in reality supports unlawful persecution of supposed homosexuals. Obviously, the concession isn't functioning. In addition, the military is not doing itself any good by escalating the releasing of homosexual service members. The military already face staffing deficiencies, and by discharging homosexual service associates in big amounts, they are dropping men and women who are prepared to serve our country (Hughes, 2000).

Nowadays, there are twenty five countries that permit gays to openly serve in their militarily, including Canada. The British military started permitting gays to serve in 2000. Affiliates of the Ministry of Defense told the New York Times in 2007 that there had been no documented episodes of aggravation, conflict, and blackmail or harassment, nor any erosion of unit solidity or military efficiency. In Israel there have been no limitations on gays serving in the military since 1993. In Russia, individuals who have troubles with their distinctiveness and sexual partialities, as the military procedures put it, are permitted to serve just during times of war. A lot of other countries forbid homosexuality in civilization in general, making gays' serving in the military a mute issue. In the U.S., yet, a lot of people think it's time for the military to get closer to with the times. As a country that is constructed on the idea of equal opportunity we should recognize and embrace change that will construct a stronger, more solid military (Webley, 20101).

Some political operatives in Washington dispute that this is not the time to change the policy, in the middle of two wars. In fact, rather the opposite is correct. This is precisely the time. We must be enlisting and keeping the finest and brightest throughout our unusual war on terrorism, which is thought to going to take a lot of time to win. Those identical people also dispute that don't ask, don't tell is still a politically sensitive issue, as it was in 1993. This isn't true anymore. Polling again and again demonstrates overwhelming support for permitting gays and lesbians to serve openly, including a majority of churchgoers, conservatives, and Republicans. Nearly no other public-policy matter does this well in polls amongst all demographic sets (Sarvis, 2009).

Outlooks within the military, predominantly amid military personnel in their 20's and 30's, who are fighting America's 21st-century wars, are altering, as well. Seventy-three percent of those coming home from Iraq and Afghanistan say they are at ease with lesbians and gays. The majority of all armed forces families support getting rid of the ban, as does Gen. John Shalikashvili, Democratic former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and William Cohen, a Republican and a previous defense secretary (Sarvis, 2009).

The American public, comprising conservatives, overwhelmingly sustain repeal. A 2009 Gallup poll demonstrated sixty nine percent of Americans, together with 58% of Republicans and 60% of those who attend church weekly, are in favor of revoking the law. Retired four-star Army Gen. Colin Powell has also stated his support for retraction. Even though shrouded in words about shielding unit solidity, at its center don't ask, don't tell is founded on a prejudice in opposition to gay and lesbian Americans. There is no observed proof that open gay service would have any harmful force (Cleghorn, 2010).

An inside Pentagon study has revealed that the majority of U.S. troops and their families don't care whether gays are permitted to serve openly and think the regulation of don't ask, don't tell could be done away with. This study's conclusions are predicted to be utilized by gay rights supporters to strengthen their fight that the 1993 law on gays could be revoked right away with little damage done to the… [END OF PREVIEW]

Two Ordering Options:

?
Which Option Should I Choose?
1.  Buy full paper (5 pages)Download Microsoft Word File

Download the perfectly formatted MS Word file!

- or -

2.  Write a NEW paper for me!✍🏻

We'll follow your exact instructions!
Chat with the writer 24/7.

Conscription in Turkey Essay


U.S. Military Bias Challenges Present in Overcoming Essay


Labor Relations the Military Policy of Don Term Paper


Sexual Assault Policies Involving Military Members Term Paper


Diversity in the Military Term Paper


View 91 other related papers  >>

Cite This Research Paper:

APA Format

Homosexuals in the Military.  (2010, November 21).  Retrieved January 18, 2020, from https://www.essaytown.com/subjects/paper/homosexuals-military/5190

MLA Format

"Homosexuals in the Military."  21 November 2010.  Web.  18 January 2020. <https://www.essaytown.com/subjects/paper/homosexuals-military/5190>.

Chicago Format

"Homosexuals in the Military."  Essaytown.com.  November 21, 2010.  Accessed January 18, 2020.
https://www.essaytown.com/subjects/paper/homosexuals-military/5190.