Labor Relations Case Studies the Effectiveness Essay

Pages: 5 (1489 words)  ·  Style: APA  ·  Bibliography Sources: 2  ·  File: .docx  ·  Level: College Senior  ·  Topic: Careers

Labor Relations Case Studies

The effectiveness and proficiency of labor unions in dealing with the practical issues that arise in the workplace has been a matter if great debate since these organizations were first founded, and the question is still unresolved. Though there can be little dount that labor unions have given more power to employees through the practice of collective bargaining, they are also necessarily highly bureaucratic organizations, responding to change with deliberately and purposefully slow agreement. In addition, and in part due to the slow nature of their actions, unions and the employees they represent can evince a certain shortsightedness in determining what is truly best for the labor force in both their recommendations and their actions. Cost saving measures proposed by management representatives are generally met with resistance by unions and the general labor force, as they almost always (by definition) lead to a reduction in pay and/or other benefits enjoyed by labor. Yet without certain cost saving measures at certain times, labor could quite realistically find themselves without a company to work for.

Get full Download Microsoft Word File access
for only $8.97.
One of the more contentious issues that falls into these lines surprisingly neatly -- at least in the United States, where there is no national plan -- is healthcare. Providing healthcare has become standard for large employers, and presents one of the most necessary benefits to employees (given the high cost of private, individual insurance), but is also one of the highest costs to management. When a company (or the entire economy) is facing a financial downturn, healthcare is often one of the first things management will turn to in an effort to reduce costs and keep the company afloat. Though labor often balks at the reduced coverage/higher personal costs of any such changes, it also helps to ensure that they will have a job in the future, highlighting one of the basic inefficiencies of the current labor relations system.

Essay on Labor Relations Case Studies the Effectiveness and Assignment

In case study 7.2, management decided to change insurance carriers when the company's current provider announced a significant increase in cost and a large sum of up-front payment as an assurance against the company's ongoing financial struggles. The only significant change in coverage, according to the case study, was a reduction in prescription benefits. The specifics of coverage are not detailed in management's contract with the union; all that is technically provided for is "basic medical benefits covering reasonable and customary charges." Given te financial straits that the company was in, and the extreme flexibility of the contract, the cost savings presented by management's decision to change insurance providers made the decision very reasonable, ensuring continued coverage without losing employees.

In this light, it seems unreasonable for the union and employees to reject the new medical plan solely on the grounds of the reduced prescription coverage. Though their cost for prescriptions would be higher than the flat four-dollar rate, after reaching their deductible amount the new plan would still cover 80% of prescription costs. For most employees, it can safely be assumed that prescription costs would not become prohibitive under the new plan, especially with the availability of cheap generic prescriptions. Regardless of the actual rise in costs to the employees, however, there is nothing in the contract between labor and management that prohibits this change on management's part, and given the financial circumstances of the company labor ought to be willing to make this slight concession in order to ensure job security.

This issue raises a very important question regarding the actual role of the union. The primary purpose of a labor union is to represent their employees. At the same time, the union must ensure that mutually beneficial agreements can be reached between he labor force and management. This can require the union not only to negotiate with management, but alsa (in certain specific instances) to negotiate with the employees in order to develop an effective strategy for continued employment and benefits. This should in no way be construed to mean that the union's task is to continually convince employees o agree with management's preferred business strategy, but in certain situations -- such as the case at hand -- convincing employees to accept the management's decided course of action is better for the company and the employees at large in the long-term. The union is not merely representative of its employees current views, that is, but must represent their long-term interests, sometimes in spite of themselves.

As stated above, the management in this instance had… [END OF PREVIEW] . . . READ MORE

Two Ordering Options:

Which Option Should I Choose?
1.  Buy full paper (5 pages)Download Microsoft Word File

Download the perfectly formatted MS Word file!

- or -

2.  Write a NEW paper for me!✍🏻

We'll follow your exact instructions!
Chat with the writer 24/7.

Statistical Case Study

Labor and Union Studies Essay

Labor and Collective Bargaining Term Paper

Labor Relations Lot of U.S. Nationals Term Paper

Wal-Mart Case Issues: CI#1: Consumer Term Paper

View 200+ other related papers  >>

How to Cite "Labor Relations Case Studies the Effectiveness" Essay in a Bibliography:

APA Style

Labor Relations Case Studies the Effectiveness.  (2009, June 27).  Retrieved October 31, 2020, from

MLA Format

"Labor Relations Case Studies the Effectiveness."  27 June 2009.  Web.  31 October 2020. <>.

Chicago Style

"Labor Relations Case Studies the Effectiveness."  June 27, 2009.  Accessed October 31, 2020.