Validity vs. Reliability in an Assessment A2 Outline Answer

Pages: 4 (1331 words)  ·  Bibliography Sources: 4  ·  File: .docx  ·  Level: College Senior  ·  Topic: Teaching

¶ … Reliability/Validity

Validity vs. Reliability

When an assessment instrument has validity, it accurately measures what it is designed to measure. An instrument with reliability consistently yields the same results every time it is used. Whether validity or reliability is more desirable with respect to a test instrument depends on the purpose of the test and how the results will be used. A teacher who develops a test for an individual classroom will probably be more interested in the validity of the test. It will be important to determine whether students are meeting learning goals and objectives. Assessments that are developed for large populations and used repeatedly, such as standardized tests, should be valid, measuring achievement as they are designed to do, but also reliable, providing a standard by which students are assessed at the district, state, or national level.

Shank (2006, p. 5) asserts that test assessments are not the best way to determine the quantity and quality of learning that has taken place but, nonetheless, practical, easy to use, and thus commonly employed. As Shank points out, "The optimal assessment type depends primarily on whether the objective is declarative (facts: name, list, state, match, describe, explain…) or procedural (task: calculate, formulate, build, drive, assemble, determine…). Research shows that there is a big difference between these two types -- the difference between knowing about and knowing how (practical application to real-world tasks)."

Download full Download Microsoft Word File
paper NOW!
In any case, validity of a test instrument speaks to its quality as an assessment tool. An instructor might not realize a test is not valid until after it is administered and the results are tabulated. If most students in the class do poorly, for example, the instructor needs to look at unit or course content, reflect on delivery methods, and try to figure out where the breakdown occurred. If most students fail to do reasonably well on a test, it is not a valid measure of the intended learning objectives.

TOPIC: A2 Outline Answer on Validity vs. Reliability in an Assessment Assignment

A recent article in Education Digest points out that "assessments that accurately reflect traditional ways of knowing for a specific cultural group can provide richer and more valid results (Culture and Assessment, 2011, p. 44). The authors cite as an example a question on a standardized test that asked students to write about the disadvantages of using laboratory animals for research. The answers of native Hawaiian students reflected the belief that there is "no such thing" as laboratory animals, that all animals are our human brothers and therefore not used for experimentation. This is but one example of the cultural bias that skews the validity of test results. In an individual classroom and often within a school or district, creators of test instruments can take into account cultural norms and traditions and thus largely eliminate this kind of bias. For instruments administered on the national level, however, it is much more difficult because our population is so diverse, both in terms of socioeconomics and racially, culturally and ethnically.

Testing is supposed to be a learning experience that focuses on what students know (Petress, 2007, n.p.). Guidelines for developing valid instruments are the same for instructors whether their students are in elementary school or in college. Test questions must be clear and unambiguous. There must be a connection between the material covered in class and the questions asked. Students must be able to prepare for the test by participating in class and working with the materials provided for instruction. For a first grade test on addition, for example, instruction components would include group instruction, guided practice with manipulatives and independent practice with worksheets. At the college level, instruction components would include lectures, class discussions, texts, and supplemental reading materials. In both cases, a valid test instrument would test students on the knowledge they developed through use of these materials. "Tests need to be clear in form and purpose, goal centered, assessed with learning in mind, be well connected to class discussions, text, outside readings, and class activities; and not come as a… [END OF PREVIEW] . . . READ MORE

Two Ordering Options:

Which Option Should I Choose?
1.  Download full paper (4 pages)Download Microsoft Word File

Download the perfectly formatted MS Word file!

- or -

2.  Write a NEW paper for me!✍🏻

We'll follow your exact instructions!
Chat with the writer 24/7.

Validity and Reliability Questions of a Study Thesis

Reliability and Validity Baum Et Al. ) Article Review

Exploring Reliability and Validity Essay

Qualitative vs. Quantitative Research Essay

Respondents of the Study ( Population Characteristics) Methodology Chapter

View 200+ other related papers  >>

How to Cite "Validity vs. Reliability in an Assessment" A2 Outline Answer in a Bibliography:

APA Style

Validity vs. Reliability in an Assessment.  (2011, April 19).  Retrieved December 2, 2021, from

MLA Format

"Validity vs. Reliability in an Assessment."  19 April 2011.  Web.  2 December 2021. <>.

Chicago Style

"Validity vs. Reliability in an Assessment."  April 19, 2011.  Accessed December 2, 2021.